| Turkey’s
Refusal To Take Part In The War
I
was personally pleased...
by
Jean Lambert
The
Green Party has adopted a consistent principled stand against the war.
We are standing firm on this now and we still consider that this was an
illegal invasion.
That arguments and excuses given that this was a war dealing with weapons
of mass destruction are simply not best dealt with through physical force.
Such action implies that the more powerful you are the less likely you
are to be invaded.
For us as a Party, it is imperative that we return to working through
international institutions and through observing treaties.
For many
years I have been trying to raise the human rights issues of the Kurdish
people in the European Parliament.
Since the war began, there is no doubt that we have seen greater attention
paid to the situation of Kurdish people.
How unfortunate that it has taken such violent and illegal action to do
so. Many people are much more aware now of the difficulties they face.
Although,
in some respects, the situation of the Kurds actually made perception
about the invasion complicated, you can understand how for Kurds living
within Iraq's borders that the war could be a positive way forward.
However, equally, for the Kurds living within Turkey's borders it could
prove far more repressive.
The question now is how do we use the possibilities that have been opened
up by this action in order to secure human rights for the Kurdish people
and their recognition as a people combined with greater political autonomy.
I was personally
pleased to see Turkey's Parliament refuse to allow the United States to
use Turkish bases.
The focus that has naturally been on the Kurds of Iraq, should allow us
now to talk about the plight of Kurds elsewhere, such as Turkey. We need
to make sure we link the issues of the people across those existing borders
and to look at an overall settlement which brings recognition with the
states.
The impressions
I have about the plight of Kurds in Turkey since the war started is that
there has been little improvement. On the contrary we are still seeing
intense monitoring and scrutiny.
The recent arrest of Ilisu Dam campaigner Nick Hilyard and of those that
were with him looking into the implications of the new pipeline for people
on the ground is just one example.
The judgement from the European Court of Human Rights about the sentencing
of Adullah Ocalan is also throwing up problems for the Government, although
they could start blaming this on the previous regime and work for improvements.
Indeed, how the Government responds to these public legal challenges is
going to be very important. They could make a start by improving Ocalan's
prison conditions before moving him to a retrial.
On the matter
of the banning of HADEP, the issue of banning political parties is highly
problematic.
Of course we have the current example in the EU itself of the Spanish
Courts upholding the ban on Batisuna.
We can say that the Parliament is following the issue of HADEP closely
and that the issue has been raised formally in Parliament and with the
Turkish Authorities.
Regarding
the imprisonment of Leyla Zana and her colleagues, the European Parliament
will be sending an official delegation to the second stage of her hearing.
Obviously as a former Sakharov prize winner for the Parliament, we feel
a special responsibility towards her and her colleagues.
How will EU negotiations now be pressing on with Turkey after its mixed
reaction to the war and the somewhat mixed messages from the AKP government
about its position on fulfilling its human rights and civil rights obligations
as embodied in the Copenhagen Criteria?
Enlargement
has raised many issues for the Parliament, only some of which are now
being addressed. We have to solve the problem of Cyprus which has become
ever more pressing as Enlargement becomes a reality.
When we are looking at future relations with Turkey we also need to remain
alert to the influence of the US within this. Before the invasion of Iraq,
the US was most supportive of Turkey's admission to the EU.
It is not clear now if that will now still be the case.
Also we do have to take into account the views of the new EU countries
who may have a different perspective on Turkey's membership. What we have
to reinforce with Turkey's Government is that human rights and economic
stability are inseparable.
They cannot solve their economic problems until they have dealt with their
human rights problems.
There is
a huge problem generally in Iraq concerning aid and the future of refugees
from both within and outside the country. The Parliament will want to
see movement on this subject and, given that colleagues of mine from the
Green/EFA Group visited the Maxmur camp not so long ago, I know we will
have a vested interest in wanting to see the safety and security of the
people currently living there.
So what is
the outlook? I tend to be optimistic by nature but there is no doubt that
the situation is very difficult and that the current instability externally
will not help the internal stability of Turkey for example.
On a more positive note, though, the strong statements from Kurdish leaders
in Iraq about seeking autonomy rather than independence have been both
useful and reassuring.
Again we need to stress that the Turkish Government has more to gain by
taking a positive response on human rights than it does by continuing
repression.
|